PhilokaliaKnowledge Map

Eschatology & Afterlife

Why There Is No Purgatory

Orthodoxy prays for the departed and believes those prayers avail, and it has never taught a purgatory. The Latin doctrine supposes a place of temporal punishment where a debt of satisfaction still owing after forgiveness is paid off, and each of its parts is foreign to the Orthodox mind: that sin leaves a quantity of punishment to be discharged, that the discharge happens in a distinct place, and that its length can be reckoned or shortened by indulgence. Orthodoxy speaks instead of souls awaiting the Judgment in a foretaste of what is coming, helped by the prayers of the Church, and refuses to say more. St Mark of Ephesus argued exactly this at Florence and refused to sign.

Sources

  • St. Mark of Ephesus, First Homily on Purgatorial Fire (Council of Florence, 1438)
  • Synod of Jerusalem (1672), Confession of Dositheus, Decree 18 the Acts and Decrees
  • St. John of Damascus, Exact Exposition IV.27 NPNF

Connections

Find on the map